png.png)
Disclosure: This is a sponsored post in partnership with Ritani. I may receive compensation for featuring this content. As always, I only share resources I believe may be valuable to my readers.
Getting engaged to the love of your life is an exciting feeling all couples should experience. Thankfully, an affordable diamond engagement ring helps you commemorate the occasion without breaking the bank. There are many legitimate jewelers with a wide selection of options, from lab-grown to natural and readily available to customizable. Here are nine of the best affordable diamond engagement ring sellers online.
1. Ritani
Ritani offers some of the best affordable engagement rings, with a selection of natural and lab diamonds. It sources all directly and handcrafts every engagement ring in its New York facility. That way, you get a unique piece of jewelry that will suit your tastes and ensure your chosen diamond fits perfectly.
Key Features
- Includes warranty
- Provides a free diamond report for every stone
- Delivers a breakdown of costs and markups for diamonds
- Provides financing options to pay in manageable installments.
Review
“Excellent experience, can’t believe the price I paid for my 1.67 carat, neither could the jeweler who was placing the diamond. Received an excellent price from Ritani (and Capital One extension found a 35% off promo). The diamond met high standards with no visible flaws and less than a nice 1 carat from Art of the Jewel. Shipping was fast and packing was sharp!”
2. Blue Nile
Blue Nile is one of the best jewelry experts in the industry that can deliver a wide variety of engagement ring styles. You can choose either natural or lab-grown diamonds through its Design Your Own Jewelry program. There are also rare-colored diamonds that can create a more unique piece of jewelry for your partner.
Key Features
- Provides professional jewelry appraisal
- Offers a diamond price guarantee
- Gives free and secure shipping on every U.S. order
- Sets up a user-friendly website where you can browse diamonds by shape
Review
“I am really pleased with the engagement ring I purchased. I designed it through your “design your own ring” section and was worried the ring would look quite different from what I saw online but I was wrong. They do a good job of portraying what the ring will look like in actuality. The customer service is superb and truly 24/7, each member I talked to was very helpful and kind. Highly recommend buying through Blue Nile.”
3. Eragem
Eragem offers various unique jewelry, from vintage and antique to sapphire engagement rings. You can also get lab-grown diamond rings fixed onto preowned mountings for a meaningful piece of jewelry. New pieces are posted every weekday, and you can look forward to seasonal discounts and markdowns.
Key Features
- Includes warranty
- Offers free overnight shipping
- Provides complimentary ring resizing
- Allows easy financing with a buy now, pay over time scheme
Review
“I couldn't believe the deal I got on her vintage engagement ring. It was EXACTLY what I was looking for at less than I expected to pay (by a lot). The ring was perfectly described. Maslow walked me through every step of the way - absolutely professional.”
4. Brilliant Earth
Brilliant Earth is a pioneer of sustainability within the jewelry industry. It repurposes sustainable materials and applies energy-efficient practices. It also ensures all pieces are sourced and crafted ethically, extending compassion toward its communities. Explore a variety of collections and create a ring you’ll love.
Key Features
- Includes a lifetime warranty
- Offers free shipping both ways, allowing 30-day returns
- Provides promo codes and offers
- Sets up a user-friendly website where you can browse diamonds by color and shape
Review
“For me, the real pick is the blockchain-tracked diamonds – a really awesome innovation that allows you to be certain of the origin of the stone and knowing the backstory of such a financially and emotionally significant purchase really appeals.”
5. Rare Carat
Rare Carat first operated as a managed marketplace business before fully transitioning into a diamond jewelry retailer. It combines AI tools and expert gemologist reviews to help you find the natural or lab diamonds best suited for your dream engagement ring. You can also get a free quote with its partnered jewelry insurer.
Key Features
- Offers a 100% money-back guarantee
- Allows free 30-day returns and resizing
- Gives Buy Now, Pay Later financing options
- Provides a best price guarantee
Review
“Buying our loose engagement stone from Rare Carat was a great experience! We were nervous about buying a loose stone online but after doing a lot of research and with their 30-day guarantee, we decided to get our main stone from them, and it was absolutely stunning! We worked with a local jeweler to build the rest of the ring custom, but we saved over $5,000+ on the main stone by buying with Rare Carat compared to our local jeweler's prices for similar stones! Highly recommend them!”
6. Aurate New York
Aurate New York ensures it has carefully crafted high-quality and sustainable rings. Operations are local, and excess materials are recycled to avoid markups. Pieces are also created on a made-to-order basis to skip inventory costs. Jewelry is made to last a lifetime and can serve as a future heirloom for your loved ones.
Key Features
- Offers a section for rings under $500
- Accepts returns within 15 days and exchanges within 30 days
- Offers discount codes, which can be used with a gift card
- Provides a lifetime guarantee
Review
“More beautiful in person! The quality and shine of this ring are top-notch. The stone is bigger than I anticipated and the gold band is dainty, yet sturdy!”
7. Clean Origin
Clean Origin sells beautiful diamonds with integrity, prioritizing environmental responsibility and customer transparency. Explore ethically created designs that use conflict-free natural and lab-grown diamonds.
Key Features
- Offers free shipping both ways
- Provides a 60-day return policy
- Gives free resizing services
- Sets up a user-friendly website where you can browse diamonds by shape
Review
“This is the greatest decision I could’ve ever made on purchasing my fiancé‘s engagement ring. The shipping was smooth, fast and easy. They did a fantastic job. Thank you so much, Clean Origin.”
8. LisaJewelryUS
LisaJewelryUS handcrafts fine jewelry that customers can purchase with confidence. It ensures all stones are conflict-free and environmentally friendly, while the bands are made of recyclable metal. You can design your own unique ring or get a ready-made one. Look out for seasonal sales on the website to get value for your money.
Key Features
- Offers a one-year free warranty
- Provides free shipping within the U.S.
- Accepts multiple payment methods and cards
- Sets up a user-friendly website where you can browse diamonds by shape or shop by gemstones
Review
“They say better things come to those who wait, and it's true. This ring is absolutely gorgeous!! Thank you so much!”
9. Shane Co.
Shane Co. crafts timeless jewelry you can shop for online and in physical locations across the country. Personalize your pieces by adding an engraving and choosing a natural or lab-grown diamond from the selection. You can also speak to a gemstone expert who can guide you through the process.
Key Features
- Offers a free lifetime warranty
- Provides free express shipping
- Gives free care, cleaning and resizing
- Allows $0 down special financing with a Shane Co. Credit Card
Review
“Fantastic experience. Amidst a pandemic and economic impact, I was still able to fulfill the standards of the engagement ring I have always envisioned for my fiancé. I worked with James S. and he deserves recognition for his part in helping me choose that 'just right diamond.' Thanks again.”
Other Factors to Consider When Shopping for Engagement Rings
Picking out an engagement ring is a personal and emotional process, but you must keep a level head to stay on budget. To keep your feet planted, here are several considerations when shopping.
Price range
What people deem as affordable is subjective to their own finances. Try to determine a price range that aligns with your current money situation, and look for a brand that offers a selection that fits it.
Variety
Viewing different engagement ring styles can help you gauge what you like and don’t. Seek a jeweler who has a wide selection you can compare and contrast. It’s ideal if they can also walk you through the differences.
Customization
Customization is essential if you want to create a unique engagement ring for your future fiancée. Some jewelers have you start the process by choosing a setting, while others prefer you pick a diamond to base the whole piece on.
Shipping terms
Open and honest shipping terms are key, especially if you’re looking for affordable diamond engagement rings online. Look at the fees and whether there’s a return policy. There should also be warranties to protect your package.
How to Find the Perfect Diamond Engagement Ring
Are you overwhelmed by how to find a diamond engagement ring for the right price? Give yourself grace throughout the process and take it slow. Ideally, you start the search as early as possible so you don’t have to rush yourself and your jeweler. Here are some key notes to think about:
- Note down your partner’s preferences: Does your partner prefer silver or gold metals? What kind of stone size do they seem to like in rings?
- Understand the 4Cs: The cut, color, clarity, and carat weight of a diamond greatly influence its price. Figure out what your priorities and non-negotiables are for the stone.
- Set a budget: Once you’ve finalized your ideal specs for the 4Cs, it’s time to set a budget. Remember to be realistic when you’re outlining it.
- Browse and narrow down: Find brands in your price range and start a collection of listings. You can also get a quote for a customized ring. Aim for at least 10 options before narrowing it down and choosing the one you’ll propose with.
What Are the Best Affordable Diamond Ring Options?
Getting an affordable diamond engagement ring means committing to your forever partner while financially prepping for the future with your savings. Create a meaningful piece of jewelry you’ll cherish together.
